AL’s best 3-man rotations
Last year, the NY Yankees rode a three-man rotation in the playoffs to a World Series title. With the playoffs less than two months away, which teams in the American League have the best three starting pitchers to make it out of the short playoff series? Let’s take a look at the AL teams fighting for playoff spots:
Texas Rangers: Cliff Lee (lhp), CJ Wilson (lhp), and Tommy Hunter (rhp). When the Rangers beat out the Yankees in the bidding for Lee, the Rangers became that much better by adding a legitimate ace. Lee could end the season with more wins than walks (right now he has 10 wins and just 9 walks). Lee proved his dominance over the Yankees (and everyone else) last year in the World Series (and playoffs) for the Philadelphia Phillies.
Wilson had quietly emerged as the Rangers ace before the acquisition of Lee after spending last season as the team’s closer. Wilson always seemed to be slotted against the opposition’s aces and was coming up a winner in the first half (despite not making the All-Star team). Opponents are hitting just .216 against him. Wilson has struggled a bit as of late with the walks, but that may be attributed to the innings he is racking up. Hunter has dominated since coming off the DL in June to a tune of a 9-1 record and a 3.01 ERA. Hunter could prove to be the dominant right-hander slotted between lefties Lee and Wilson, especially since he is more rested after missing the first two months.
NY Yankees: CC Sabathia (lhp), AJ Burnett (rhp), and Andy Pettitte (lhp) or Phil Hughes (rhp). This three-man rotation (with Pettitte) dominated in the playoffs in 2009 but this year’s group has not been as dominating. Pettitte is on the DL and Burnett has been inconsistent. Burnett has struggled against playoff contenders and with his control. Hughes could step in if Pettitte (or Burnett) are not ready, though the Yankees are trying to limit his innings. Pettitte is almost unbeatable in the postseason (a matchup with Cliff Lee would be entertaining). Sabathia has not lost at home and has been good against playoff contenders.
Chicago White Sox: Mark Buehrle (lhp), John Danks (lhp), and Gavin Floyd (rhp). Floyd won Pitcher of the Month for July as he has been the AL’s best pitcher so far in the second half (after an abysmal first two months). He has given up just two homeruns once the calendar turned to June and has walked just nine batters after the All-Star break. Danks has also been dominant since the All-Star break, going 4-1 with a 2.91 ERA. Will the amount of innings that Danks and Floyd have thrown hurt them in the postseason? Buehrle has been inconsistent but is the ace. He has also struggled against the Rangers, Yankees, and Rays.
Minnesota Twins: Carl Pavano (rhp), Francisco Liriano (lhp), and Scott Baker (rhp). I think the Twins rotation will be what keeps them out of the playoffs come October. When you name Carl Pavano as your most consistent and reliable starter, that’s trouble (no matter how many times he beats the Yankees). Pavano has earned 14 victories with an ERA under 3.30 and has been more dominant so far in the second half. Liriano has been dominant at times, though some of the struggles have come against the division and on the road. He does keep the ball in the ballpark (he has allowed just two homeruns in 2010). Baker has also struggled on the road and has not been the dominant pitcher he was in 2009. Nick Blackburn has been banished to the minors and maybe he can regain his form there. Brian Duensing has been a pleasant surprise since moving from the bullpen to the rotation.
Tampa Bay Rays: David Price (lhp), Matt Garza (rhp), and James Shields or Jeff Niemann (rhp). Price could be headed towards a CY Young award in his second season in the majors and has quickly become the dominant force in the Rays young rotation. Garza has been inconsistent though he has recently pitched a no-hitter and thrown better in the second half. Shields’ season has been disastrous though he has pitched well against the Yankees. Niemann could get the nod in a short series, especially if his shoulder heals after his stint on the DL.
Boston Red Sox: Josh Beckett (rhp), Jon Lester (lhp), and Clay Buchholz (rhp). The Red Sox have been hit by the injury bug time-and-time again. Lester and Buchholz have anchored the rotation. Beckett has been solid since coming off the DL and should be fresh for the postseason (plus he pitches his best then). Lester and Buchholz may be Price and Lee’s biggest competition for the CY Young award. Lester started off terrible in April but has recovered to a 12-7 record and a 2.94 ERA. He also has pitched well against playoff-contending teams. Buchholz currently leads the AL in ERA (2.49) and has been dominant so far in August (2-0 with a 1.54 ERA in three starts).


































Recent Comments